10 tactics from industry experts to protect brand profit over the holidays

The holiday season is a catch-22 for retailers.

It’s the biggest sales event of the year, with many brands generating more revenue in a few days than they do in a full quarter.

But research from Klaviyo’s consumer shopping report reveals that price range is the top factor in purchase decisions for 70% of consumers globally. This means that to win those sales and new customers, brands have to discount.

Anecdotal evidence supports this, too. In my conversations with Klaviyo customers of all sizes, there’s one universally agreed upon tactic for the holiday season: discounting is a requirement.

That’s a tough pill to swallow. Discounting cuts into margins, and retailers already have some of the lowest margins in business. Inflation and shipping costs certainly don’t help.

All of this can make the holidays feel less like a big revenue-driving moment and more like a big squeeze: you have to participate, and it’s a race to the bottom on price.

But what if there’s a different approach?

I’ve sought out advice on how to protect profit during the holiday season from a handful of Klaviyo customers. At the core of many of these tips is operational efficiency and the flow-on effect it has on the bottom line, with customer experience always a consideration.

So, from the easy to implement and so-simple-it’s-silly to more strategic executions that require longer lead time, I sincerely hope these tips and tactics help you win new customers, hit sales records, and blow past revenue milestones this holiday season.

1. Ensure customer lists are squeaky clean

On average, you should clean email, SMS, and mobile push lists once per quarter to improve your reputation, deliverability, and most importantly save on costs. Here are some easy steps to follow.

2. Segment customers based on size

Customers who fall outside bestselling sizes are often willing to pay full price for items that are in stock and actually fit. You can test this tactic alongside other segmentation strategies for BFCM.

3. Be dynamic with discounting

The right approach to discounting depends on what you sell, your target audience, and the customer experience you’re creating. Discount codes give you control over pricing and promotion, and dynamic codes can help protect your brand and profit margins as they limit oversharing. Learn how to set up static and dynamic coupon codes.

4. If you’re not using AI, you must start

Operational efficiency impacts profit, so working smarter, not harder is pretty sound advice. With Klaviyo AI, you can quickly create segments, campaigns, and flow logic.

Check out these resources to get you up and running:

• Segment with AI
• Prepare your basic flows using AI
• Build BFCM campaigns faster with these top AI prompts
• Culture Kings case study

5. Use SMS for time-sensitive messages

When used wisely, SMS is a superpower with high conversion rates. Beyond product drops and discounts, there’s significant opportunity with curating advanced replenishment flows that align with a subscriber’s unique place within the customer journey, like SMS reordering reminders. This approach worked for esmi Skin Minerals when they switched from Emarsys to Klaviyo for email and SMS.

6. Integrate to automate returns

Returns can have a significant impact on profitability, customer lifetime value, and loyalty, so increasing automation and providing a seamless customer experience during peak periods can never be an afterthought.

Learn more about Klaviyo’s 350+ pre-built integrations, including many with returns and shipping platforms.

7. Create and nurture a B2B segment

B2B is touted as one of the biggest growth opportunities in commerce and many D2C businesses are setting up the tools to help capitalise on it. If you have a wholesale customer base, one simple tactic is to create a segment and communicate with them frequently. Learn more about Shopify tags in Klaviyo.

8. Extend your attribution window

The increase in data available along the customer’s journey means attribution discussions have become increasingly complex. Choosing the right model enables you to identify where you can optimise, allocate budget, and drive ROI. Brush up on Klaviyo attribution or dive straight into the Elevar integration.

9. Fuel the customer content engine

In the noise of the sales season, brands need to differentiate themselves. Leaning into your unique customer community and encouraging content creation can be an impactful and cost-effective tactic to test. Learn how swimwear brand Kulani Kinis used Klaviyo’s Gatsby integration to automate micro-influencer management, and download Klaviyo’s guide to UGC for more tips on executing this strategy.

10. Create a jumbo-sized product

Profit Peak’s Carla Penn-Kahnrecently shared this tactic from a local beauty brand. Creating a larger, or “jumbo” product size can result in less frequent re-purchases, but a decrease in shipping costs, fees and packaging, as well as a shift in the scarcity mindset of customers, resulting in greater profitability.

This isn’t a tactic to implement for BFCM, but evaluating new approaches to your products and seeking customer feedback can start now, in advance of 2025.

Your next step

Find more BFCM tips and tactical advice in Klaviyo’s BFCM hub. You’ll find resources like case studies, use cases, how-to articles, research, guides, courses, and Help Center content to make sure you can implement everything you want in time for the season.

And remember: consumers are shopping earlier and earlier each year. Don’t wait until November to get started. Start now.